Mascara

Reddit Rankings (by upvotes)

96 discussions analyzed

...

R/30PlusSkinCare: Mascara without the raccoon eyes 28 Jun 2025
R/30PlusSkinCare: Finally found a routine that works for me! - 34 yrs old 08 Jun 2025
R/30PlusSkinCare: Farmacy green clean not taking off mascara?! Alternatives? 07 Aug 2023
R/AmazonVine: Counterfeit …. A fake Thrive Mascara popped up today 23 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: My holy grail mascara! (Canmake Metalook Mascara) 10 Jun 2025
R/AsianBeauty: First time using Clio Kill Lash 18 May 2025
R/AsianBeauty: Rave/Review Judydoll 3D Curling Mascara - before and after 14 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: My AB Makeup 12 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: your favourite mascaras for a natural lifted look? 15 Nov 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Unpopular Opinion: Heroine Make Mascara is better than Clio Kill Lash 11 Nov 2024
R/AsianBeauty: My Eid Makeup Routine in Tropical Climate (during 'Summer') 12 Apr 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Mascara review with pictures 29 Feb 2024
R/AsianBeauty: CLIO kill lash superproof mascara or HEROINE MAKE by KissMe? 27 Jan 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Favourite AB purchases of 2023? 13 Nov 2023
R/AsianBeauty: [First Impression Review] Cezanne Lasting Curl Mascara: a mascara that REAAALLY holds a curl!!! 02 Apr 2023
R/AsianBeauty: [Review] Dolly Wink Volume Mascara 06 Mar 2023
R/AsianBeauty: Comparing 3 popular asian mascaras + non-AB recommendations 19 Dec 2022
R/AsianBeauty: Brown mascara AB review: Rom&nd mascara and Heroine Kiss me mascara 23 Jul 2022
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara after 10 hours, a flash typhoon, and a trip to the beach 04 Jul 2021
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara vs CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara 21 Jun 2021
R/AsianBeauty: CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara Long Curling 20 Jun 2021
R/AsianBeauty: Etude House Lash Perm Curl Fix Mascara does👏not👏mess👏around! 19 Mar 2020
R/AsianBeauty: Asian mascaras are the best! (Kiss Me Heroine Long and Curl) 02 Dec 2018
R/AsianBeauty: [Discussion] Anyone else feel that they have a makeup immune face? I will probably struggle with mascara + lip products my whole life 26 Jun 2018
R/AsianBeauty: [Discussion] Removing Heroine Make Mascara 30 Aug 2017
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Advanced Film Mascara ad- Beautifully ridiculous at all times. 09 Jun 2016
R/AsianBeauty: What is your HG mascara? 07 Jan 2016
R/beauty: Best mascara you’ve used? 18 Mar 2025
R/beautytalkph: I did my own grad shoot makeup! 🥳 20 Jun 2025
R/beautytalkph: Korean Idol Lash Style with Clio Kill Lash Long Curling Mascara 08 Oct 2024
R/beautytalkph: Brutally Honest Reviews of Budget-Friendly Makeup from a Broke College Student 26 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: I finally found the perfect mascara (at least for me) + 14hrs wear test 06 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: Heroine Make Mascara 01 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: break-up proof, cheater-proof, miracle in cell no.7-proof mascara ♡ 02 Jul 2024
R/beautytalkph: The OG Heroine Make Eye makeup 19 May 2024
R/drugstoreMUA: Mascara like Maybelline Sky High that doesn't smudge??? 14 Jul 2024
R/drugstoreMUA: How does the regular L'Oreal Telescopic Mascara compare to the waterproof version? 11 Jul 2022
R/KoreanBeauty: everyday mascara 26 May 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: korean mascara and eyeliner recs for oily eyelids? 21 Apr 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Help Me Build an Asian Beauty Skincare and Makeup Routine (Budget: around $150) 11 Jan 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Asian Beauty Skincare and Makeup 11 Jan 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Western version of Clio Kill Lash mascara 02 Dec 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: Removing ROM&ND Han All Fix Mascara / mascara mascara 22 Jul 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: FF going to Seoul soon, what should I get? 12 Jul 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: [REVIEW] KISSME HEROINE LONG & CURL MASCARA ADVANCED FILM SUPER WATERPROOF 16 May 2021
R/KoreanBeauty: Does anyone know of any great oil-based cleansers that will remove Etude House's Curl Fix Mascara? 01 Apr 2021
R/Makeup: High end mascaras are a scam. 29 Apr 2025
R/Makeup: is the loreal telescopic application supposed to look like this? 18 Apr 2025
R/Makeup: Is the essence lash princess waterproof mascara good? 25 Mar 2025
R/Makeup: Drugstore mascara? 22 Mar 2025
R/Makeup: Is the Maybelline Sky High Mascara worth the hype? 04 Apr 2024
R/Makeup: Still searching for the tubing mascara holy grail- and Thrive is NOT it 10 Dec 2023
R/Makeup: What mascara do you swear by? 08 Sept 2023
R/Makeup: What mascara do you swear by? 08 Sept 2023
R/Makeup: 3 year review of thrive mascara 05 May 2023
R/Makeup: Loreal Telescopic Lift 21 Jan 2023
R/Makeup: Why is Thrive mascara so cheap on Amazon? 25 Nov 2022
R/Makeup: Thrive tubing mascara vs Benefit They're Real 31 Oct 2022
R/Makeup: Thoughts on Thrive makeup 12 Feb 2022
R/MakeupAddiction: Do y’all have any CC for my default “full glam” face? I like how I look in it well enough but I also feel like it feels somehow… disjointed or lacking cohesion or something like that? 25 Jun 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: DIY wedding makeup trial 1 - looking for thoughts 09 Jun 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: basic makeup vampy lip 30 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: do I suit cool tone or warm tone makeup better ? (Pic 1= cool, 2=warm) 15 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: I drew my everyday makeup routine! 14 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Hamster approved basic glam (swipe for pics w/ hammie 🐹) 06 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: my attempt at blonde bombshell makeup :DD 05 Feb 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Best mascara you’ve ever used? 12 Jan 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Cherry Cola All Drugstore Makeup 18 Dec 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Tubing mascaras: Alleyoop vs Thrive 30 Oct 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Clio kill lash mascara 07 Sept 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: my makeup before + after 13 hours of flying 27 Aug 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: What is your MUST have mascara 04 Jun 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Impossible to remove Loreal Telescopic waterproof mascara 29 Dec 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: What’s your holy grail mascara? 18 Sept 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: Suggestions for strongest waterproof eye makeup remover? 10 Mar 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: My holy grail mascara—heroine make long and curl mascara 22 Dec 2017
R/makeupflatlays: The products I use in every look, my ride or dies 🫡 21 Dec 2023
R/muacjdiscussion: Makeup products that make you irrationally angry 24 Mar 2023
R/Sephora: Tubing Mascara Recommendations 27 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: Best brown mascaras? (that are ACTUALLY brown) 11 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: desperate for a mascara that will hold a curl 09 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: which mascara would you pick? 06 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: Glow without glitter 21 May 2025
R/Sephora: Mascara holy grail? 23 Mar 2025
R/Sephora: All-time favorite mascara? 15 Jul 2024
R/Sephora: Yes/no to Tarte’s Tubing Mascara? 08 Jun 2024
R/Sephora: What’s your most favourite mascara and why? 26 Feb 2024
R/Sephora: Unpopular opinion: Expensive mascara is worth it 24 Oct 2023
R/Sephora: Mascara recommendations for gals with straight downward facing eyelashes - please! 05 Oct 2023
R/Sephora: What mascara is good? 18 Aug 2023
R/Sephora: Best makeup remover for sensitive skin? 01 Aug 2023
R/Sephora: What is the most dispointing makeup you ever bought? 30 Jun 2023
R/Sephora: Best make up remover for waterproof mascara? :) 21 May 2023
R/Sephora: Best makeup remover for super waterproof mascara? 17 Aug 2022
R/Sephora: What was your go to mascara this year? 01 Jan 2022
R/Skincare_Addiction: Help! Eyelash care after mascara 23 Aug 2023

Essence Lash Princess (Multiple Variants)

12627 Aggregated Upvotes

118 positive, 48 negative reviews

Clio Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (Multiple Variants)

4276 Aggregated Upvotes

131 positive, 39 negative reviews

Maybelline Sky High Mascara

2430 Aggregated Upvotes

129 positive, 37 negative reviews

Heroine Make Mascara

1458 Aggregated Upvotes

217 positive, 55 negative reviews

Loreal Telescopic Waterproof Mascara

508 Aggregated Upvotes

94 positive, 30 negative reviews

Thrive Mascara

306 Aggregated Upvotes

226 positive, 68 negative reviews

glossier lash stick

175 Aggregated Upvotes

87 positive, 25 negative reviews